Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Diana van Eyk's avatar

Good article, Mike!

Expand full comment
Paul Snyders's avatar

Well said, Mike!

I spent a few years in an online photo group, which had a couple of sweet and brilliant white South African members, and I remember being astonished at the visual telltales they could not help but show. The juxtaposition of stunning beauty and barbed wire was outright creepy – and the proliferation of almost medieval looking defenses for otherwise normal houses made me sad for those on both sides of that divide of having and of violence. Free play between cultures is a fantastic bounty (and I never take that fortune for granted, though Toronto is, for all its faults, especially good at bringing many together).

I’m a bit weird for being a poor kid in a rich country, and doing better over time, but never losing my immediate awareness of the way things work for those on the bottom (which you captured perfectly). Power indeed despises those who can neither threaten nor bribe it! And policy splits between citizens the powerful do fear and care about, versus those who are functionally rendered untermenschen, have not been so starkly revealed here, in the better part of a century. (They made me add “Well meaning psychopath”) to my collection of definitions of malign “Libtards” (who have always pissed me off, even just for betraying once precious classical liberalism – to which we all owe so damn much).

Of course Toronto is a world away from that level of desperation and tension – but I saw a funny story today which reminded me of the complete ignorance of the powerful, when it comes to those they rule.

The provincial government is about to pass a law that allows them to give certain classes of “special constables” who do official government security in many settings, but are not full police officers, weapons, when this is deemed appropriate. Opposition parties are screaming –and of course pointing out the examples which make this sound silliest (solving campus high-jinx does not need a Glock).

But when I saw the special constables for government housing projects on the list, I understood immediately that the law was needed and sensible, and why. Years ago we had a high-murder summer which was widely called “The Summer of the Gun.” Baffled City, Provincial and even Federal politicians weighed-in on the question, with solemn faces and pious bullshit in heaping quantities. But no one had anything useful to say, or any insight whatsoever into what caused the problem.

But I stay in touch with poor people, so I understood that the “Summer of the Gun”came FROM THE ACTIONS OF THOSE STUPID POLITICIANS. Specifically, the city set aside hundreds of millions to redevelop one of the most violent gang-filled public housing project downtown (Regent Park) –and instead of thinking about the actual culture they were dealing with (rival gangs) they sent families from that project, directly into projects which were entirely controlled by hostile gangs (instead of allies).

So what we had was a blood feud gang war created by government “Helping and charity”policy (with a big helping of dopey idealism instead of specific awareness of realities and relationships, on the side).

Of course South Africa has far more entrenched problems on every level, especially competition for resources one class is used to stealing (and feeling it their right), and another huge class badly needs, but the more I read your stuff, the more I suspect one common element for the“Elites” who are driving all of us nuts in common with their combination of confidence and incompetence, is the refusal to engage with reality in a full sense, and an insistence instead on twisting and denying it, to reify dogma.

Cheers man!

Expand full comment
5 more comments...

No posts